When it comes to integrating technology into a lesson, whether old or new, it definitely brings some new energy and excitement for teaching it. The same can be said whenever an exciting new idea jumps into a teacher's head on how to teach a concept to his or her students. For me, I feel that there is most-definitely a reason to keep a tight grasp on my level of excitement. Control...plain and simple, control. Call it paranoia, call it negativity, call it realistic, call whatever you want, but when you are up in front of 24 students and things aren't working, you will understand where I may be coming from.
The first main area where control becomes a concern is with the reliability of our technology. Planning a whole lesson, activity, or project around technology could be risky. Internet connections, log-in issues, and software updates always seem to pop up around us and take time to fix (sometimes too long). So the question when planning is, "How much "back-up" planning do I need to do if something doesn't work?" By no means do I want to double-plan a lesson "just-in-case" something doesn't work, however, there have been more than enough times when things aren't working correctly and I felt as though I was standing there with a big spotlight shining on me while my brain quickly decided how we were going to switch gears. It isn't that this is always a big deal, we are teachers, and this is what we do. However, looking ahead at my class for next year, and knowing that I have several students who have needs that require a good deal of modification and who also don't always do well with sudden changes, it makes me a bit more cautious...or maybe nervous.
Being able to control things/fix things when issues come into play is the second area where control comes into play. I completely understand that I am not the only teacher in my district, and while I may think that the issues that I may be currently experiencing are the MOST important and should be taken to the top of the to-do list, in the big picture, may not be. But to a teacher who has spent time planning and organizing, prepping and building up his/her own excitement for the lesson, an unexpected technical issue can be a HUGE deal. One of the current frustrations at our school is that the issues that seem to impact students the most, are put on the back burner, while the problems that, while very important, don't impact them as much, get taken care of with more immediate attention. This is not to sound like a whiny teacher, but rather, one that would like a little information on why some of the problems that seem simple to solve, seem to take forever to actually get solved.
I may have digressed a bit from the original question, and aside from the impression that the tone of this post may have given off, I really enjoy using and having my students use technology whenever possible and find it to supply great benefit to student learning.
Jessica -
ReplyDeleteI know I feel your pain when it comes to technology working the way you want it to. For me it usually happens when my administrator is doing one of his "3 minute walk-throughs" or when I am trying to give an in-service to the staff, lol. I think it is a bit much to expect that we always have a Plan B because that is not the expectation with any other lessons. If a lesson goes wrong, and it will, we rely on our quick thinking skills and we learn from it. Often times when I have colleagues or parent helpers in the computer lab they are always impressed with how quickly I can troubleshoot and fix things and I simply tell them "I've made lots of mistakes and now I know what to expect". And that is the truth. Like Sir Ken Robinson says, we can't be afraid to make mistakes or we'll never come up with anything original. Haha
I completely understand your feelings. Even the smallest glitches kill momentum, and momentum drives successful lessons. However, the more you use technology, the quicker you become at managing the problems. Besides, it is a true test of your performance skills when things go awry.
ReplyDeleteYour school seems to have their priorities inverted, but that is common in the current environment.
Jess I agree with our district having issues being admin tech before students. I have heard that $750 has been spent on an Ipad to be a model set up for ones we MAY get in the future. Very interesting thought! That is a lot of money we could use on In the classroom tech.
ReplyDeleteI can completely understand where you are coming from and at the same time part of me wants to find better ways to embrace a lack of control if that makes any sense at all. I think you are absolutely right about glitches and reliability problems and the word David used, "momentum" seem to be the most accurate. I worked in television for a short while and in education now, but close to all of the healthcare IT and in both of these settings glitches are NOT an option. Technology can be reliable, but it requires extra effort and investment to make it so and that can't be expected of the teachers. Do you think you would feel more comfortable using technology in your class if the school provided immediate support and the technology was reliable?
ReplyDelete